Should we be recommending STI testing for all sexually active heterosexual men?

A male patient talks to a health care provider

When it comes to getting tested for sexually transmitted infections (STIs), there are some basic guidelines that apply to everyone who is sexually active regardless of sex, gender, or sexual partners. The most obvious piece of advice is to get tested right away if you have any symptoms like itching, burning, sores, or discharge. Of course, a lot of STIs have no symptoms, so it’s also a good idea to get tested when you have a new sexual partner or if you have multiple sexual partners  

There are other more specific screening recommendations for certain populations. For example, the CDC recommends that sexually active women under 25 get tested for chlamydia annually. There are also specific recommendations for gay, bisexual, and other men who have sex with men and for transgender and gender diverse persons. Missing from this list—heterosexual men. Instead, the CDC recommends “risk-based” screening for this population.

Why are there no universal screening recommendations for hetero men?

Screening recommendations are about setting priorities and making the biggest impact with the available resources. With limited funding, emphasis is on groups where infection is common and harm is greater. Young women, for example, are more susceptible to chlamydia infection, and the potential long-term consequences include infertility. Because infection is less common and the health impact less severe, widespread screening for STIs in hetero men is deemed “not cost effective.” 

Should heterosexual men be a bigger priority in STI prevention efforts?

At the recent national STI Prevention Conference, Dr. Ina Parkauthor, sexual health MD, and UCSF professor—argued that we should be thinking differently about screening for hetero men. For one thing, heterosexual men are the ones passing STIs to heterosexual women. We can’t successfully address the rising rates of STIs—especially syphilis—in hetero women without getting men involved.  

She also pointed to data that suggests risk-based screening of hetero men is not working in part because too few providers take a sexual health history. Without this information, they can’t accurately assess risk.  

Dr. Park noted that men of color are disproportionately affected by STIs and could stand to gain the most if we are successful in STI control efforts among men. “Excluding hetero men from messaging around STI testing,” she concluded, “sends a message ‘your sexual health is not a priority.’”   

Ahead of her presentation, Dr. Park took her case to social media with her characteristic humor and a survey.

The response has been near universal—99 percent of those responding agree that providers should recommend STI testing for all sexually active heterosexual men.

Do you agree?

Should health care providers recommend STI testing for all sexually active heterosexual men?

More to Explore

An African American woman looks pensively in the distance

Emotional Issues with Herpes

Herpes may raise strong emotional issues, especially in the first few weeks or months after a diagnosis. Some people initially feel embarrassment, shame, anger, or depression. The good news is that these emotions tend to fade away over time. Some studies have shown that even

A person holds a teal ribbon in their hands

Coping with Cervical Cancer

Listen as cervical cancer survivors discuss diagnosis, treatment, and survivorship, and offer advice to others facing a diagnosis.

An older couple resting their heads together smiling

Sex After 50—Sexuality As We Age

Sex can be part of life well into our later years. While we may face health challenges as we age, we can still continue to enjoy a satisfying sex life.

ASHA AIDS Quilt, an artifact from our history

Our History

ASHA was founded in 1914. This timeline traces our history over our first 100 years.

Menopause

Menopause and Sexual Health

Despite negative stereotypes, as well as some actual difficulties women can face during this time, many women report that once they’ve reached menopause they feel more confidant, stronger, and energized than they did before.